Recruiter interview questions

A recruiter shapes every candidate’s first impression of your company. The first round should show how they find people, how they treat the ones they turn down, and how they keep a hiring manager on track without letting the process slip.

10 questions for a recruiter first round

Pick three to five that fit your role, rather than all ten: a short first round gets more finished interviews. All ten together take about 23 minutes to record. The time limits suit a one-way video interview, where each answer is recorded once.

  1. 1

    Tell us about a hard role you filled. How did you find the person you hired?

    Listen for: Creative sourcing beyond job boards, persistence and a clear account of what made the search hard.

    3 min to answer
  2. 2

    How do you work with a hiring manager to agree what a role really needs?

    Listen for: A structured intake conversation, pushing back on unrealistic wish lists and agreeing the must-haves.

    3 min to answer
  3. 3

    Describe how you keep candidates informed through a long process.

    Listen for: Regular updates even when there’s no news, and clear timelines.

    2 min to answer
  4. 4

    How do you tell a candidate they haven’t been successful?

    Listen for: Promptness, honesty and kindness, with useful feedback where possible.

    2 min to answer
  5. 5

    What do you do to make a hiring process fair to every candidate?

    Listen for: Structured questions, agreed scoring, diverse sourcing and awareness of bias.

    3 min to answer
  6. 6

    Tell us about a time a hiring manager wanted to skip steps in the process.

    Listen for: Understanding the pressure, explaining the risk and finding a faster way that kept the process sound.

    2 min to answer
  7. 7

    Which numbers do you track to know your recruiting is working?

    Listen for: Time to hire, source of hire, offer acceptance or quality of hire, and what they did with the numbers.

    2 min to answer
  8. 8

    How do you manage many open roles at the same time?

    Listen for: Prioritising by urgency and difficulty, and keeping every candidate moving.

    2 min to answer
  9. 9

    Describe a time a candidate turned down your offer. What did you learn?

    Listen for: Finding out the real reason and changing something for the next offer.

    2 min to answer
  10. 10

    What makes a great candidate experience, in your view?

    Listen for: Clarity, speed and respect, with specific examples.

    2 min to answer
Scoring

Signs of a strong candidate

  • Finds people beyond the obvious places
  • Treats rejected candidates with respect
  • Manages hiring managers firmly but kindly
  • Uses numbers to improve, not to impress

Agree what a 3 and a 5 look like for each question before anyone watches, and save your own rating before reading your colleagues’.

Use them

Run these as a video interview

  1. Save your chosen questions as a question set in AsyncView, with the minutes for each.
  2. Create an interview for the role, import the set and pick a deadline.
  3. Paste your candidates’ names and emails. Each gets a private link.
  4. Watch, rate and compare answers with your team, then shortlist.
How question sets work
More roles

Questions for similar roles

All roles
Keep reading
All guides

Send these questions to your recruiter candidates today.

Candidates record their answers in their own time; your team reviews together. The Free plan includes 5 interviews and needs no card.

Start for free (opens in a new tab)See how it works