AsyncView

Being fair to candidates in an async round

Recording yourself answering questions into a laptop is a strange thing to ask of someone. A few decisions make it much less strange, and none of them cost you anything.

Let us be honest about what we are asking. A candidate finishes work, sits down at a kitchen table, and records themselves talking to a camera with nobody on the other end. It is uncomfortable, and treating it as normal is the fastest way to lose the people you most wanted to hear from.

Say what happens next, in the invitation

Four things, before they click:

  • How many questions there are and roughly how long the whole thing takes.
  • How many attempts they get per question.
  • When the link closes.
  • When they will hear back, and from whom.

That last one is the one teams skip and the one candidates care about most.

Keep the round short

Four questions. Fifteen minutes end to end. Anything longer and you are asking for an evening, unpaid, before anyone at your company has spent a minute on them. The asymmetry is already steep — do not widen it.

Allow retakes on the human questions

The first thing anyone says on camera is not representative of them. Give at least two attempts on anything where nerves would distort the answer, and reserve the single-take question for the case where you genuinely need an unrehearsed response.

Reply, including to the no

The strongest argument for a recorded round is speed, and speed is worth nothing if the rejection still takes three weeks. If you can review a shortlist in one sitting, you can reply the same week. Do.

A fast no is a real feature of this format. Teams that use it get a reputation for it, and it comes back to them in the next round of applications.

Leave a route back to a person

Some people cannot do this — bandwidth, disability, a shared living situation with no quiet hour. Put a contact address in the invitation and offer a live call instead. It will be used rarely, and the people who use it are not the people you want to lose.

More on screening, structure and running a hiring round that respects everyone's time.

Screening at volume without lowering the bar

Four hundred applicants and one recruiter is a filtering problem, not an interviewing one. What to automate, what to keep human, and where the bar actually slips.

Read article

Put it into practice

Five interview credits, no card needed. Write the questions once and let candidates answer on their own time.